Top 10 Best Amazon Mascaras At A Glance
• All options are available for 2-day prime shipping.
• These mascaras deliver length, volume, and definition.
• You should experience no flaking or clumps.
• Everything is from the drugstore on a budget.
As a beauty reviewer, I test mascaras all the time that are lackluster. I have put together a comprehensive guide on the best Amazon mascara. Each of these are their top 10 best sellers daily. The mascaras discussed here will give you volume, length, and definition, all without clumps, flakes, and smudging. Those are my critiera when judging a mascara. I have a detailed review of each.
To make this article, I looked up the Amazon best selling mascara on their page. Now, this page changes daily with sales. Below is the screenshot from the day that I looked. Even though it can vary, these are normally the top 10. Looking for great mascara on Amazon Prime? They are all available for one or two day shipping!
1. essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
The insanely low price, in conjunction with the quality, is what gets people so obsessed with it! Years ago, I wrote a roundup on the best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes and this mascara is covered there. I still stand by it after all of these years! It has a tapered wand that evenly coats each lash. This formula gives length and volume for a dramatic look. The hype is real and much-deserved.
2. L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara
This is a classic OG option from the drugstore. Formula-wise, this mascara is uniquely lightweight. The soft bristles account for zero clumps, so that you get a thick and lengthy look. I once had this in burgundy and it was super fun! Their primer from this line one of my holy grails.
3. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
It lifts and lengthens lashes. It has a rather skinny, yet slightly tapered silicone wand that is flexible. This is a great option to get that fluttery, dramatic look. BONUS: they make a primer for this mascara and it on its own is incredibly impactful. Pairing the two together is unnecessary, but wild at the same time.
4. L’Oreal Paris Telescopic Original Lengthening Mascara
The fourth best mascara to buy on Amazon has such a skinny brush, so much so that you would not expect to get length and definition. This mascara delivers! You will get that separated, fluttery look. As you can imagine, this is also good for bottom lash application.
5. L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara
It delivers intense volume and length. Its hourglass-shaped wand grabs your lashes from root to tip, providing a voluminous, fluttery look. This is designed to be a dupe for Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara, right down to the wand shape.
6. elf Clear Brow & Lash Mascara
This is best reserved for natural makeup looks, or no makeup days. Its clear formula has a light hold, without making the hairs stiff or crunchy. You really will not get length or definition.
7. Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara
This features a unique silicone wand that is curved along with short and long bristles. This is good for grabbing every lash, even in the inner corner. It will build your lashes to maximum impact. This is an example of a formula that hits its prime in a few weeks, as it starts rather wet and messy. Do not loose hope! You will get that feathered look soon.
8. Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara
This mascara thickens lashes without weighing them down. Its brush features patented silicone bristles that coat lashes from root to tip. There is also a good amount of flexibility. I accidentally bought the waterproof! The packaging design of keeping the wand separate is ultra pleasing.
9. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara
This Maybelline number returns again in this list, with its waterproof option at number nine. Waterproof mascara is always a good idea if you know that moisture may wreak havoc on your look, such as watery eyes and weddings. It works just as good as the standard formula. You will get all-day volume and length without smudging or flaking. Waterproof mascaras can be hard to wash off, and often require an oil-based makeup remover. My tutorial on how to remove makeup easily has you covered.
10. L’Oreal Voluminous Panorama Mascara
This has a tapered wand with short and long bristles. It gives you a wide-eye effect. It is rather bold with volume and definition. The packaging is ultra luxe.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best mascara on Amazon?
The best mascara on Amazon really comes down to your preferences. While you can shop by best sellers, you should consider if you want waterproof vs. regular, and what effects you are looking for. Reading reviews is always recommended.
Is it safe to buy mascara from Amazon?
It is safe to buy mascara from Amazon, as long as you have a sharp eye. I try to buy from the brands themselves, as shipped by Amazon, instead of third party sellers. Reading reviews and checking star ratings is a good idea to see what you are getting yourself into.
What is the #1 selling mascara?
There are endless interpretations out there on what is the #1 selling mascara, and it varies from store to store as well as reviewer to reviewer. It is safe to say that the mascaras in this lineup are consistent best sellers across the board.
Shop The Mascara
These continuous top-sellers can be trusted to give you serious drama with length and volume. What are your preferences when shopping for a mascara? Until next time, continue to let your true beauty shine.
