best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes

Best Drugstore Mascara for Feathery Lashes

All products are independently reviewed and tested. Clicking on any links may result in The Aesthetic Edge earning a commission. Read our disclosure here.

Testing new mascaras is not my most welcome task because I have my reliable favorites that I hate to stray from. Believe it or not, all of my favorites that are on holy grail status come from the drugstore! I like the head turning, va va voom look, and I will settle for no less. When you think about it, that look is often feathery and voluminous, kind of like a pair of false lashes. I am compiling my loves into this list of best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes. I stand behind all of these mascaras, and I predict you will have better lash days in your future. Time to get started.

best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes
best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes

Prep & Prime

Before I talk about the best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes, we need to discuss prepping the lashes for mascara application. I always start by curling my lashes, otherwise they stick out straight. Next, I apply Loreal’s Voluminous Primer. It is the only mascara primer that I know of that actually enhances any mascara and makes it look that much better.


Related Post: Best Inexpensive Makeup Brushes


loreal voluminous primer

What I Look for in Mascara

To give some context on my selections for best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes, it is helpful to know what I look for in mascaras for them to make the cut. In the introduction to this post I lean into the fact that I want bold lashes and steer far away from a subtle or natural look. A good mascara should lengthen, separate, add volume, and otherwise make the lashes look feathery. I am looking for drama and that false lash look. None of these mascaras get flakey on me or rub off onto my skin.

Three out of four of these mascaras feature hourglass-shaped wands. Those types of mascaras usually provide long, full, voluminous, feathery results. Please note I am not opening all of the mascaras for pictures because the tubes are new and I do not want the formulas to dry out before I can use them.

The Mascaras

Now I will reveal the best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes one by one.

Loreal Voluminous Lash Paradise

Lash Paradise is often marketed as a dupe for Too Faced’s Better than Sex. While I have never tried the high-end counterpart, visually they look similar. All of the hype that you hear on this mascara is true, and I like it over anything else I have tried from Loreal.


Related Post: Long Lasting Eyeshadow Primer


loreal voluminous lash paradise

Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift

The wand on The Falsies Lash Lift is a bit larger than some mascaras, but it still does a lovely job of bringing on the feathery, false lash effects. I cannot say if it is truly a replacement for a professional lash lift, which is a bit far reaching, but it does its job effectively.

maybelline the falsies lash lift

Essence Lash Prince False Lash Effect Mascara

Essence’s Lash Princess is the only mascara in this bunch that does not have an hourglass wand. Rather, it is tapered by going from thick to thin. This mascara is a perfect example of not needing to spend very much to get an exceptional mascara.

essence lash princes false lash effect mascara

Maybelline Lash Sensational

Lash Sensational has a unique formula. For the first week or two it is very wet and makes your lashes look like a hot mess. Do not give up on her too early! Once it it hits its prime, this stuff is the real deal. All of the other mascaras in this blog post have a formula that is ready to go right out of the gate.

maybelline lash sensational full fan effect mascara

Shop the Post

Conclusion

To conclude the best drugstore mascara for feathery lashes list, all of these mascaras are my all-time favorites that are on holy grail status. I will not settle for a low impact mascara, instead I want full-on drama with a feathery look. All four of these mascaras deliver and are dependable. Best of all, they are highly affordable, with the cheapest starting at $4.99. Who needs false lashes on a daily basis when you have these babies waiting in the wings? Until next time, continue to let your true beauty shine.

What other mascaras should be added to this list?

More of the Best of Beauty Series:

Best Contour Palettes Best Valentine’s Day Eyeshadow Best Matte Makeup Best Travel Makeup
Best Fair Skin Highlighter Best Electric Razors Best Inexpensive Makeup Brushes Best of Maybelline
Best At-Home Skincare Tools Best Multitasking Beauty Best Non-Drying Liquid Lipsticks Best Drugstore Sponges
Best Makeup Under $5 Best Bronzer For Fair Skin Best Blush For Fair Skin Best Cream Makeup Products

In This Article

Picture of Amanda Vitale
Amanda Vitale
Hi, I am Amanda Vitale, the owner of The Aesthetic Edge. I am a beauty and style expert who has been writing reviews and advice for 10 years. I have had the pleasure of testing hundreds of products, and I have published countless lookbooks. You can see my expertise quoted in top authoritative publications such as Bustle and Real Simple. I have also worked with your favorite brands, such as CurrentBody and AXIS-Y.
Now Trending
Recent Articles
Connect
Subscribe

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience. By continuing to browse on this website, you accept the use of cookies for the above purposes.