wet n wild Fantasy Makers Ballerina Horror Collection Review, Swatches

wet n wild Fantasy Makers Ballerina Horror At A Glance

---

• There are 43 products in the collection scattered across several retailers.

• Some items are repeats from previous years.

• Some items are new innovations for the brand.

• A handful of products have been recolored but kept the same name.

I have what is new from the wet n wild 2024 Fantasy Makers Halloween collection! Allow me to help you in deciding what to buy with my detailed reviews including swatches, star ratings, and a spooky makeup look.

Details

Each year the collection becomes harder to purchase due to wet n wild’s nightmare of a distribution system. There is no real release date. When it comes to where to buy, everything is scattered across several retailers.

Walmart got the displays in-store in late August. However, they didn’t get the full collection. I bought what I could from that display, then I placed an order on the CVS website to get most of what was missing. I also got a few items in Five Below in store.

For online shopping, you can find small selections on Walmart, Ulta, Amazon, and Five Below. CVS has the most, but not all. Select CVS stores got a good majority of items in store. Five Below got a small display in store. If you are local to HEB you probably found some items too. I will mention this again when I get to the artificial nails later.

You may notice that items are “missing” from this review. Several items are repeats from previous years. I do not rebuy them (well, a few I accidentally rebought and included here) but you can use the search bar in the menu above to look up the product. I also have a list of links at the bottom of this article connecting you to previous years.

Please note that I do not buy the stencils, paints, or glitters. Those are not practical to me and a waste of money. I will say, the cost of everything in this collection is very attainable with nothing going over $7.

Here is a rundown of the wet n wild Fantasy Makers Ballerina Horror repeats from previous years:

• Some of the gem face masks
• Zombie contour palette
• Some of the paints
• Some of the stencils
• 1 glitter gel
• 1 artificial nail set
• 1 of the individial gems
• Glow in the dark sponge
• Black lipstick
• Black liquid lipstick

I will also note that some products have the same name from previous years, but, the colors were changed, which I have comparisons of.

Makeup Body Sponge

We have seen the giant makeup body sponge in previous years, but purple is a new color. As the name implies, it is a bit too large for use on the face with foundation. It is better for the body, or to quickly cover your face with paint if you are looking for speed without so much precision.

I am a major fan of their sponge material. It expands when wet to become super bouncy and soft. It absorbs little product and is easy to clean. You will get the most beautiful blend.

Claims: This should be a super soft sponge designed to blend creams, liquids, and powders with a larger surface area for face and body. It is versatile and made from hydrophilic material to prevent makeup waste. It should expand to twice its size when wet and become extra soft for smooth, seamless application. You should end up with a streak-free blend every use.
Rating:

Gem Face Mask

With the Gem Face Masks I note that Bone to Shine and Clown Tears are new. While Moonlit Maven is a repeat, it has been recolored this year. I normally keep the previous items for comparison purposes, however, I am afraid that I have decluttered or otherwise misplaced my gem face masks. You can compare the new Moonlit Maven to the old with Fantasy Makers Circus Sauvage.

If you are buying these in store, especially in Walmart, please note they are mixed up on the pegs. You need to search through them to find what you are looking for.

I do not have any use for these. I have never stuck them on my face and I am always curious how they would adhere and last over makeup.

Claims: These colored gems are iridescent and self-adhere for easy application. They can be mixed and matched and are also simple to remove.
Rating:

Moonlit Maven

Bone To Shine

Clown Tears

Nail Accents

We get two sets of nail accents, and they are both repeat names with the colors changed. I have the comparisons for you below. I do enjoy their nail stickers! They are easy to apply with tweezers and last when you use a top coat.

Claims: These stickers self-adhere to the nail over any nail polish. They bring salon-quality results at home that are easy to stick on and remove.
Rating:

Silent Scream

Trick Me, Treat Me

Shine & Shimmer Hair Mist

Hair mist is a new product for wet n wild! The colors are gorgeous. Please note that you do want to shake these well. The major hangup is that this formula is oily! I have NO desire to spray these on my hair. It is going to be oil city. What a disappointment.

Claims: These hair mists contain a blend of argan oil, rosemary leaf extract, and sunflower seed oil for shine. The fine mist contains a dreamy glitter. They should not leave an oily or sticky residue.
Rating:

Crushed Moon

Fallen Star

Trio Highlighter in Cosmic Dust

This highlighter is very metallic and frosty, perfect for costuming but maybe not for the everyday. There is some glitter in there but it is not offputting. This is wet n wild’s signature formula that you can easily build to your desired intensity. I am including an individual and a blended swatch.

Claims: This highlighter is infused with ultra-reflecting pearls. You can wear the shades alone or blended for a multidimensional look.
Rating:

False Lashes in Pink Dolly

We only get one set of false lashes with wet n wild Fantasy Makers Ballerina Horror, and they are entirely new. I usually dock them a star because their lashes have a cheap appearance with a thick band. This set is pretty and the pink is a nice touch. Perfect for Halloween, maybe not for other purposes.

Claims: These lashes add length, volume, drama, and texture to your look. They should be easy to apply and compliment any eye shape. The band is flexible and sized to fit anyone.
Rating:

Glitter Body Illuminator

wet n wild generally does a bad job with body illuminators. They had three in their core line which they rightfully discontinued. They have also tried them in limited edition collections, all of which I decluttered. The only one that was actually good was from the wet n wild Nightmare Before Christmas collection because they tried a water-based formula. Water-based allows it to last all day without transferring everywhere, while avoiding a greasy feeling.

They are back to oil-based here. That means the product feels oily in the skin, and the glitter transfers to your clothes and everywhere else. I have no desire to use them further. You do need to shake them well.

Claims: These are oil-based illuminators that enhance your skin with light-reflecting pearls and nourishing ingredients. You should get a natural, healthy sheen.
Rating:

Pink Sorcery

Fountain Of Gold

Glow In The Dark Glitter Gel in Fairy’s Touch

You already know that I am a major fan of the glitter gel! We only get one new shade this year. Their formula is water-based so that it dries down comfortably on the skin and lasts ALL day! I love using these for accents around the eye or on the high points of my face. They wash off pretty good but you can enlist the help of some clear tape to remove the glitter too. This is like body glitter for adults and it is divine!

Claims: This gel formula is super-concetrated with hyper-reflective glitter that you can use on your eyes, face and body. The gel is water based for easy application. This should be high-coverage and multidimensional. The formula dries fast and stays put for hours.
Rating:

Lip Gloss Stain in Vampire Venom

I know this product is the star of the collection. I admit, visually it is pretty cool. It sort of has the oil and water effect where the red is suspended in the clear. The applicatior is new for wet n wild – it is a plastic paddle.

You get an unpredictable amount of clear versus red every time that you use it, but ultimately it gives your lips a sheer wash of red tint that is super shiny. This lip gloss formula feels more like an oil, and I say that in a good way. It is lightweight and comfortable on the lips without being sticky. The more that you use the product the red starts to mix with the clear and it stays like that, thus promoting the sheer wash of color.

However, I am docking this one star because it does not stain the lips. The product wears off since it is a gloss, but no tint remains. This is a cool product but it is not going to give you a bloodstained or bloody look as compared to other products on the market.

Claims: This is a new innovation from the brand that promises a high-pigment color that stains the lips, all with a shiny finish. Vitamin E provides hydration.
Rating:

Glitter Lipstick in Poison Ivy

This is wet n wild’s signature lipstick formula, yet they claim it is new. The green metallic packs an amazing punch! The color is easily buildable. It is like a matte metallic all in one. You will find that it glides easily onto the lips and wears comfortably without causing dryness, flaking, or cracking. It holds up decently but is meant to be re-applied when needed.

Claims: This new lipstick formula gives you bold color with a multidimensional glitter finish.
Rating:

Glow In The Dark Makeup Sponge

This sponge is a repeat but I thought what the heck, let’s get another. My thoughts here are the same as those on the purple body sponge.

Claims: This sponge is made with hydrophilic material to minimize makeup waste. It should blend with ease. The rounded bottom is great for wide areas, while the tip reaches finer details.
Rating:

Chrome Lip Gloss in Celestial Romance

This chrome lip gloss packs a lot of metallic, rosy pink pigment! This is their signaure formula that is ultra shiny without being heavy or sticky. Feel free to re-apply as needed. I believe this is their first true chrome lip gloss.

Claims: This is a few formula that is infused with multidimensional shimmers and pearls to give a high shine. It is blended with shea and murumuru butter for a creamy, conditioning texture.
Rating:

Glitter Brow & Lash Mascara

We have seen glitter mascaras in previous years and other limited edition collections. The formula is ok. It does leave brow and lash hairs feeling crispy or hardened in place. You can see the glitter but you may have expected it to pack more of a punch.

Claims: This mascara has a lightweight gel formula that applies smoothly and dries quicky for comfort and hold. It can be worn on its own or combined with other mascara. The applicator deposits the right amount of glitter evenly, from root to tip. It is safe for eye use. You can apply a single layer or build it up.
Rating:

Purple Spiral

Pink Shapeshifter

Metallic Eyeliner

While we have seen metallic eyeliners in other limited edition collections, this packaging format is reverting to old school. All of the shades pack a beautiful punch, and you can layer them. They dry down to be fully matte yet metallic at the same time. If you try to layer them when wet they may ‘erase’ themselves a bit. Overall, they do what they claim to do and are long lasting.

Claims: The brush applicator gives a smooth and even application with rich pigment. They are packed with superfine glitter to give a reflective, prismatic finish. You can build them up to your desired effect. The formula is quick drying.
Rating:

Moonlight

Pink Fizz

Alienation

Individual Gems

Cauldron Crew is a repeat name, but, the colors have changed. I also do not have the old ones so I will link you to Fantasy Makers Halloween 2020 to compare. I made a mistake in re-buying Sparkling Spell thinking the colors were changed too, but they were not.

This is another product that I have never stuck on my face and I wonder how they last on top of makeup.

Claims: These gems self-adhere and can be used on the face and body.
Rating:

Cauldron Crew

Sparkling Spell

Contour Palette in Thirsty Vampire

We got a new shade of the contour palette! This palette is highly buildable and blendable. I use it both on the face and the eye. It is perfect for spooky purposes but not much outside of that. I recommend pairing it with the original white/gray option to create contour with dimension.

Claims: This palette can be used to sculpt the hallows of the checks, nose, jaw, and hairline. It gives a soft focus look that is long-lasting. The palette is portable for touchups on the go.
Rating:

Eye & Face Palette

Both of the Eye & Face Palettes are repeat names with the shades changed. I have the comparisons below. None of the shades have names, rather, they are numbered on the back.

I like both of the palettes and find their quality to be consisent. This is the wet n wild formula that we know and love. Everything is super blendable and buildable. Nothing is patchy. All formulas are easy to work with. You may get a bit of kickup or fallout and that is normal for a drugstore priced palette. I am impressed by the pigmentation and versatility.

Claims: These palettes have a buttery soft, rich pigment that should easily glide on. The finishes range from shimmer, to metallic, and glittery. They can be applied wet for more impact. Everything should be easy to blend.
Rating:

Hallow-Queen

Boogie Nights

Artificial Nails

What drama is surrounding the artificial nails! They released two new designs this year, with the third one (Pumpkin Bumpkin) being a repeat. HEB got the new nails, which is a grocery store only located in Texas. They got ONE set of nails on each display! Sometimes Rite Aid’s stock mirrors HEB. With Rite Aid recently emerging from bankruptcy, their shelves are bare and most of our stores have closed. wet n wild customer service was unable to comment on the availability of the nails. They had no clue.

With all of this being said, I am unable to purchase them. All photos are from HEB. I will still review them as I have covered them in previous years. The nails are on the larger side, which will require a lot of custom fitting for small hands. They are also thicker, so they will look less natural. The designs are quite nice and the glue does work. Having your nails last is all about the prep, not so much the glue. I would absolutely wear these for the month of October if I could acutally buy them.

Claims: These nails should be durable, comfortable and beautiful to wear featuring comfort-fit technology. The included nail glue keeps them securely in place for long-lasting wear.
Rating:

Wrapped Up

It’s A Sign

Makeup Look

Here is my full face of wet n wild makeup look, featuring the wet n wild Fantasy Makers Ballerina Horror items. I call this Goth Glam. I mixed their white color correcting concealer with their skin tint to make myself more pale without going white. I also set the look with the white contour powder. This worked very well! All of the contour palettes did great for creating dimension the eyes and face.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I purchase the wet n wild 2024 Fantasy Makers Halloween collection?

The wet n wild 2024 Fantasy Makers Halloween collection is available from Walmart, Amazon, Five Below, Amazon, Ulta, CVS, and HEB.

Is the Fantasy Makers collection vegan and cruelty-free?

The Fantasy Makers collection is vegan and cruelty-free, as this is what wet n wild practices for all of its products.

How long will the 2024 Fantasy Makers Halloween collection be available?

The 2024 Fantasy Makers Halloween collection will be available until everything sells out. These products are limited edition.

What Reddit Users Are Saying About The Collection

Shop The Collection

As to be expected from wet n wild Fantasy Makers Ballerina Horror, most of these products are not highly wearable for every day but better for costuming. What are you getting from this collection? Will you use any of it on Halloween? Until next time, continue to let your true beauty shine.

Discover More Fantasy Makers:

Fantasy Makers Festival 2021	Halloween 2020	Fantasy Makers Neon	Halloween 2019
Halloween 2018	Fantasy Makers Liquid Catsuits	Circus Sauvage	Fantasy Makers Bedeviled
Fantasy Makers The Dolls