elf Liquid Poreless Putty Primer vs. Original a Glance At A Glance
• The original Poreless Putty Primer fills all pores.
• The liquid does not fill any pores.
• Each primer provides a smooth, matte finish.
• The original dries down tacky.
This elf Liquid Poreless Putty Primer vs. Original comparison explores both primers that virtually have the same claims and benefits. I will help you decide which is best for you, and if they even work as advertised.
Details & Claims
I will start with where you can buy these primers. Since the liquid is new, it’s retailer options are still limited. These options should expand over time. You can find it on elf’s website and at Target. The original putty is the OG, so you can find it at all retailers that carry the brand. These include elf’s website, Amazon, Ulta, Target, and Walmart.
Liquid Poreless Putty Primer
Poreless Putty Primer
They have a lot in common, so I will start with the similarities. Both claim to smooth the skin and minimize appearance of pores with a translucent, matte finish. They feature squalane as the key ingredient to hydrate the skin. Additionally, they should grip makeup for long-lasting wear designed for all skin types, and even the color is the same.
The primers do diverge on packaging. The original comes in a pot, where you get 0.74 oz for $10, while the liquid comes in a $10 squeeze tube with 0.94 fl oz. elf has differed the explanation on the formulas as well. They say the original has a velvety texture, while the liquid is more lightweight with a silky texture. It is notable when considering these primers that the liquid is silicone based, while the potted is water based.
When it comes to application, each should be applied evenly to the face and given 30 seconds to dry down and set. You may use their Putty Primer Brush and Applicator with either of these, but a patting motion is best when using your fingers. The original putty is also marked for use on the eyelids.
Review
I find that both primers layer well with skincare and makeup, and makeup applies normally over top. The liquid has a smooth finish, while the potted putty is a bit on the tackier side. Each primer gives a soft and smooth matte finish. The fun does not stop here, of course! elf Cosmetics offers several different putty primers to tickle your fancy. You can find the right one in my elf Putty Primer comparison.
I have severe pores on and around my nose. The original putty fills about 90% of them, while the liquid will not fill them at all no matter what I try. The liquid also zaps the life out of dewy foundations, which is not a problem with the original. At the end of the day, each exhibit normal wear and tear. The liquid allows some oils to come through on the t-zone, as I have combination skin. The original allows more pronounced oils through.
I think both of these might extend wear time slightly. Based on these results and my skin type, it makes the most sense to use the original on my nose, and the liquid on the rest of the face. I declare that the original is best! The liquid is more of a marketing gimmick to build hype. I have more details on the liquid in my elf Liquid Poreless Putty Primer review.
| elf Liquid Poreless Putty Primer vs. Original Comparison | ||
|---|---|---|
| Poreless Putty Primer | Liquid Poreless Putty Primer | |
| Skin Type | Normal/dry/combo | Normal/dry/combo |
| Skin Benefit | Hydrates | Hydrates |
| Key Ingredient(s) | Squalane | Squalane |
| % of pores filled | 90% | 0% |
| Base | Water, creamy putty | Silicone, liquid |
| Finish | Matte, velvety | Matte, silky soft |
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Both primers layer well with skincare and makeup
- Smooth application and natural matte finish with either formula
- Original fills about 90% of visible pores on and around the nose
- Liquid is less tacky, making it good for overall face use
- Both may slightly extend makeup wear time
- elf offers several Putty Primer variations to suit different skin needs
Cons
- Liquid does not fill pores effectively
- Liquid diminishes the glow of dewy foundations
- Liquid allows oils to come through on the t-zone with combination skin
- Original lets more pronounced oils break through over time
- Liquid feels more like a marketing gimmick than a true innovation
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between e.l.f. Liquid Poreless Putty Primer and the original?
The Liquid version has a serum-like texture for faster absorption and lighter feel, while the Original is a solid balm that melts into skin for more grip and a smoothing finish.
Which one is better for oily or combo skin?
The Original Poreless Putty Primer offers a more matte, pore-filling effect that helps control shine—making it a better choice for oily or combination skin types.
Can you use both primers together?
Yes. You can use the Liquid version as a quick base layer, then press the Original into targeted areas (like the T-zone) for added blurring and longevity.
Shop The Primers
The potted putty fills the most pores, up to 90% on the worst of skin. I cannot get the liquid to fill any pores, but it makes a good general base. You can definitely use these together, but that sort of defeats the purpose. Is pore filling primer a priority for you? Until next time, continue to let your true beauty shine.
One Response
I am not sure where you’re getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for magnificent info I was looking for this information for my mission.